[Overflow]

Originally Posted by jewel25

You were quick to change your vote when she said you look guilty for voting against her.

Because I don't know what Rolltide or belle is. If Rolltide turns out to be mafia, I don't want that to reflect badly on me for defending him.

[RolltideSS]

Originally Posted by Overflow

I meant that he just doesn't have as much pull as people like Belle.

That's true I don't, i take no offense and knew what you meant

Originally Posted by Mindz

You tend to get really anxious and post happy if you're mafia (we've been mafia together before).

true but I also tend to walk away if I know i'm caught, and from my first game I get post happy if I know someone's lying as well

i'd vote for myself just as a last move but I would really like to get people to post what they saw and did from last night. what I know at this point is:

belle has lied about what she did
I did nothing
Jewel says she did nothing

no one else out of the 7 has fessed up any information. even if you don't believe me maybe pull your vote so you can see the whole night rather than voting off one persons story.

[BowtieBelle]

Originally Posted by jewel25

I think you need to stop digging that hole.

Originally Posted by Overflow

You missed what I said in my last post. If you're the mafia, it's easy to say that you're a cop, because you know that the mafia's not going to go against you. Are you a cop? Maybe. I honestly don't know. But I'm just trying to look at the situation from both points of view.

How am I making myself look guilty? All I've done is put a vote up against you.

The mafia's not going to go against me? The mafia is already going against me. I've been accused of being a liar by two people-- one of whom is the person I investigated and found to be anti-town, of course; the other jumped on the "Belle's a liar" bandwagon as soon as I said I was the cop. (you)

Sure, there's an off chance I could be the "insane" or "paranoid" cop-- I just read all the roles again-- so that argument, from you, has merit. But why wouldn't rolltide have used that in his defense from the beginning if he was trying to get people not to believe me?

I have no way of knowing anything other than what I've told y'all. I'm the "cop" (that's all I got there) and RollTide is "anti-town" (all the info I got there).

Originally Posted by Overflow

If I can out and said "RollTide is anti-town" and Rolltide came out and said "Overflow is anti town" who would you believe.



Belle's really a man.

Oh god she's gonna kill me now.

I can't kill. I'm a cop, not mafia.

Originally Posted by jewel25

You were quick to change your vote when she said you look guilty for voting against her.

Originally Posted by Overflow

Because I don't know what Rolltide or belle is. If Rolltide turns out to be mafia, I don't want that to reflect badly on me for defending him.

But on the other hand you retracting your vote makes it look like you're realizing he's doomed to go down and you want to try to avoid going down with him. Just sayin'. At the same time, since you won't side with us, you still look guilty of being mafia.

See what I'm saying?

[BowtieBelle]

Originally Posted by RolltideSS

what I know at this point is:

belle has lied about what she did

Of course, you being mafia, you would say this trying to save your skin. You have some proof that I'm lying? Again, you've never listed off any kind of real defense, as to why I would paint a target on my back, or what role you have, or anything usable. You're just screaming that I'm a liar-- which just kinda affirms your guilt.

Which is, yeah, basically the same thing you did last time we were in this situation.

[RolltideSS]

Originally Posted by BowtieBelle

Of course, you being mafia, you would say this trying to save your skin. You have some proof that I'm lying? Again, you've never listed off any kind of real defense, as to why I would paint a target on my back, or what role you have, or anything usable. You're just screaming that I'm a liar-- which just kinda affirms your guilt.

Which is, yeah, basically the same thing you did last time we were in this situation.

Every game is a new game - i don't carry a grudge

[RolltideSS]

Originally Posted by BowtieBelle

The mafia's not going to go against me? The mafia is already going against me. I've been accused of being a liar by two people-- one of whom is the person I investigated and found to be anti-town, of course; the other jumped on the "Belle's a liar" bandwagon as soon as I said I was the cop. (you)

Sure, there's an off chance I could be the "insane" or "paranoid" cop-- I just read all the roles again-- so that argument, from you, has merit. But why wouldn't rolltide have used that in his defense from the beginning if he was trying to get people not to believe me?

I did present the possibility that you are in fact the cop - there could be a mafia framer or a redirector as well that could make me look like something i'm not (framer plants evidence, redirector would make you think you are looking at me and instead have you redirect to someone else). I also said i was voting for the more likely alternative which is you are banking on your name to carry your argument to get people to lynch me. which you are

[Overflow]

Originally Posted by BowtieBelle

The mafia's not going to go against me? The mafia is already going against me. I've been accused of being a liar by two people-- one of whom is the person I investigated and found to be anti-town, of course; the other jumped on the "Belle's a liar" bandwagon as soon as I said I was the cop. (you)

Sure, there's an off chance I could be the "insane" or "paranoid" cop-- I just read all the roles again-- so that argument, from you, has merit. But why wouldn't rolltide have used that in his defense from the beginning if he was trying to get people not to believe me?

I have no way of knowing anything other than what I've told y'all. I'm the "cop" (that's all I got there) and RollTide is "anti-town" (all the info I got there).



I can't kill. I'm a cop, not mafia.







But on the other hand you retracting your vote makes it look like you're realizing he's doomed to go down and you want to try to avoid going down with him. Just sayin'. At the same time, since you won't side with us, you still look guilty of being mafia.

See what I'm saying?

There's no need to put words in my mouth. I never once said you were a liar, nor did I say Rolltide is a liar. Just because I'm a little suspicious doesn't mean I'm trying to kill everyone.

RollTide has never been in a game with a paranoid cop, so he probably doesn't even know what a paranoid cop is.

I do think Rolltide is doomed. Unless someone spits some info out, I know there's nothing that will change the direction of where the votes are going right now.

I'm just not one to vote against someone because of one persons story. If Rolltide came out of no where and said "Belle is anti town. That is all." Then I know for a fact I'd be very suspicious of him.

But the fact that the only evidence you have against me is that I'm not a follower and agreeing with you, doesn't make me look bad. It makes you look paranoid.

[BowtieBelle]

I've never been in a game with a paranoid cop, either. I didn't even know that role existed till I just read it

[RolltideSS]

Originally Posted by RolltideSS

you throw this lie out shows me you are either mafia, there is a mafia framer or there is a redirector. While I won't put it past PMC to switch things up on us by throwing out a crazy role I am going to start wih the more likely possibility that you are mafia. If you're the cop why don't you say exactly what you saw - you get more information that just anti-town you know

in case ya missed it

[BowtieBelle]

Oh and I'm not presenting your behavior as 'evidence' because it's purely circumstantial. I'm saying, to me, you look pretty guilty with what you've been doing. But I don't have any proof of that.

[BowtieBelle]

Originally Posted by RolltideSS

in case ya missed it

And I already told you exactly what my info was. Can't give you info I don't have.

You accused me of being a liar last time you were guilty, too. Just sayin'. I do not get any more info than anti-town.

[Mindz]

Originally Posted by RolltideSS

no one else out of the 7 has fessed up any information. even if you don't believe me maybe pull your vote so you can see the whole night rather than voting off one persons story.

This is a good idea. I'm pulling my vote until I can hear more from menendez and draco.

unvote rolltide

[Overflow]

Originally Posted by BowtieBelle

You accused me of being a liar last time you were guilty, too. Just sayin'. I do not get any more info than anti-town.

Using the last game as evidence in this game is useless.

[RolltideSS]

maybe I've missed something - having never been the cop, mindz/overflow do you always get a story of what you fund to lead you to conclude pro/anti town?