[FireCracker]

I don't wanna jump to any conclusion with not much to go on.

[menendez1293]

Alright I just read through all that I missed while at work and just like I stated earlier I never recieved a PM with any info last night so I have nothing to share and since I don't have a night role I didn't do anything either.

Honestly I am agreeing with Firecracker on this one. I don't want to jump to anything because we could have a repeat of the first day phase and risk killing another innocent townie.

And for Ditrimpi while I see your point on being able to use a no lynch do we really want to do that? We would basically be allowing the mafia to either kill another player or convert them.

I want to wait it out see if anyone's story doesn't add up and go from there

[RolltideSS]

Originally Posted by menendez1293

Alright I just read through all that I missed while at work and just like I stated earlier I never recieved a PM with any info last night so I have nothing to share and since I don't have a night role I didn't do anything either.

Honestly I am agreeing with Firecracker on this one. I don't want to jump to anything because we could have a repeat of the first day phase and risk killing another innocent townie.

And for Ditrimpi while I see your point on being able to use a no lynch do we really want to do that? We would basically be allowing the mafia to either kill another player or convert them.

I want to wait it out see if anyone's story doesn't add up and go from there

Everyone's story is out, nothing really to wait and see about at this point

[menendez1293]

Originally Posted by RolltideSS

Everyone's story is out, nothing really to wait and see about at this point

Oh didn't realize all had posted. Wasn't paying too much to screen names when I was reading unless something jumped out at me.

Just like last game my head is going with the lack of clues.

[menendez1293]

Ugh I meant to say wasn't paying to much attention to screen names. Left the attention part out by mistake

[Mindz]

I'm sorry guys, but the NL would have been on day 1 when we lynched mikey.

[menendez1293]

Originally Posted by Mindz

I'm sorry guys, but the NL would have been on day 1 when we lynched mikey.

This is a direct quote from either PMCs first or second post. To me it sounds like it doesn't matter when we use it.

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch/no lynch. Only allowing No Lynch one time during the whole game!!!

[menendez1293]

Originally Posted by kjkjr27

Lmfao I suck at this

Come on Kevin. Don't you have a masters in forensics science

[RolltideSS]

Carnies:

1. Mr Draco - night role?
2. mikeyg - bulletproof/ dead
3. CHMSC - drunk?
4. Firecracker - townie?
5. rolltide - townie
6. redemption - night role?
7. Menendez - townie?
8. Mindz - townie?
9. Overflow - townie?
10. Dtrimpi - town watch or cop?
11. kj - townie?
12. shnomac - tracker/dead

This is where I sit right now - my first impression is the some townies may be hiding true roles (no doctor?) my second impression is that redemption seems questionable, offering that his role was not productive but no additional information. I don't have any suspicions that would lead me to vote someone right now

[kjkjr27]

Originally Posted by menendez1293

Come on Kevin. Don't you have a masters in forensics science

Lmfao a Bachelors AND Masters lol but shhhhhhhh

[Mindz]

Redemption doesn't like to reveal his role. Either he's mafia and wants to hide it, or pro-town and doesn't want to be a target.

[Mr_Draco]

Originally Posted by menendez1293

This is a direct quote from either PMCs first or second post. To me it sounds like it doesn't matter when we use it.

It's just best for the town if it's only used on day 1. Personally I don't like NL at all.

[Dtrimpi87]

Originally Posted by Mr_Draco

It's just best for the town if it's only used on day 1. Personally I don't like NL at all.

Agreed

[Mr_Draco]

Originally Posted by RolltideSS

This is where I sit right now - my first impression is the some townies may be hiding true roles (no doctor?) my second impression is that redemption seems questionable, offering that his role was not productive but no additional information. I don't have any suspicions that would lead me to vote someone right now

Those of us who have played for awhile don't like revealing roles. It can set you up as a target plus imo it kinda ruins the game. I prefer to try and figure out who people are instead of everyone coming out and saying "I'm this".