[Corrado68]

One question for those who opted for option 3: which summer tires do you have?

The reason I ask is that I have the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 and I think that they're a bit too extreme: very, very "hot summer" oriented. Here in northern NJ we already see the low '60s in the morning and if the roads are also wet, the ABS light is turning on a bit too often for my taste.

I'm OK with running summer & winter tires alternatively, but with those Eagles you might end up with winter tires for 9 months per year, which is not my idea of fun.