View Single Post
Old 09-29-2012, 06:29 PM   #30
JusticePete
 
Drives: Camaro Justice
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Virginia
Posts: 20,171
Quote:
Originally Posted by DGthe3 View Post
You're talking as if Cadillac put the whole thing together & decided that the only other car that should be present is the 3 series. Motor Trend did the comparo and wanted to see how the new ATS stacked up against the car that they felt was the best in segment (according to a recent multi-car comparison test they conducted before they had access to the ATS). If you've got a problem with the 3 series being protrayed in the video as the car to beat, your beef is with Motor Trend -not Cadillac.


GM did not focus solely on the 3 series when they did their benchmarking for the ATS. They bought 2 of every competitor & used those cars to determine where to set their targets for each aspect of the car (ride, handling, body stiffness, erogonomics, seating comfort, materials, fit and finish, etc). This is a standard practice at any major company, not unique to the ATS, GM, or even the auto industry. But the point is, GM brass didn't just grab a previous generation 3 series and say 'build us a better one of those'.


MT Average Annual Sales
Rating


#1 BMW 3 400,000
#2 Volvo S 60 60,000 (2011)
#3 Mercedes C Class 60,000
#4 Audi A4 294,000
#5 Lexus IS 20,000

BMW owns this market by volume and magazine tests. The ATS should come in 3rd by volume in the first year of global sales
JusticePete is offline   Reply With Quote