Greatest of all time (GOAT NFL)
 

Each major position I'll rate mine and you guys agree / disagree.

I wont give my reasoning as to why I chose each... yet. I want to start it off with who I think, and whether you agree or not and then we can discuss.

Everyone here listed I feel is self explanatory if you've ever followed football, and then the health discussion comes in if you disagree.
I want to see what people think!!

QB - Tom Brady

RB - Barry Sanders

WR- Jerry Rice

TE - Tony Gonzalez

LB - Lawrence Taylor

CB/DB - Deion Sanders

QB - Warren Moon

RB - Jim Brown

WR - Jerry Rice

TE - Kellen Winslow Sr

DE - Deacon Jones

CB - Darrell Green

QB - Joe Montana

RB - Jim Brown

WR - Jerry Rice

TE - Tony Gonzalez

CB/DB - Lester Hayes

QB- Tom Brady

RB-Barry Sanders

WR-Randy Moss

DE-Reggie White

LB-Jack Lambert

CB-Derrel Revis

TE-Ben Watson

Geez... Luv Ya Blue!!!!

Coach - Oail Andrew "Bum" Phillips!!!!!

RB - Earl Campbell!

* - Bruce Matthews!

G - Mike Munchak!

DT - Ray Childress!

DE - Elvin Bethea!

LB - Robert Brazile!

WR - Billy "White Shoes" Johnson!

You musta been from Houston and now live in Co. Lots of Oilers!

Joe Montana

QB) Brett Favre

RB) OJ Simpson (its not what he did off the field its what he did on it)

WR) Jerry Rice

TE) Tony G

DE) Bruce Smith (200 career sacks playing 3-4 DE how many would he have as a 4-3?)

LB) Mike Singletary

CB) Charles Woodson

I'm curious as to why no one thinks Tom Brady is the greatest of all time.

http://www.nfl.com/player/tombrady/2504211/careerstats

96.7 QB Career rating with FOUR Superbowls.

Joe Montana is a close second, but I think Brady wins it all at the end of the day.

Though I think Brady is good, them going 3-1 with two different replacement QB's while he's been gone shows to me that this has as much to do with Belichick's coaching as the ability of Brady.

Lived there from 1979 to 2007... during the Luv Ya Blue days. Good times. :nod: All the HPD cars were even painted Columbia Blue... ;)

Just don't want the Oilers forgotten. :biggrin:

But no love for Warren Moon!

Derrick Thomas???

QB - Dan Marino (yeah, I'm bias, but I think he's done the most with the least amount of supporting cast. ie no running game and average Defense) best pure passer ever)

RB - Walter Payton (pretty much same thing as marino. people knew he was going to run, still couldn't stop him. also didn't have much as qb to help him)

WR- Jerry Rice

TE - Tony Gonzalez (gronk a close second)

LB - Ray Lewis

CB/DB - Ronnie Lott